Meltzer, Brad. I Am Gandhi: A Graphic Biography of a Hero. [Ordinary People Change the World series]. Illus. by 25 artists. Dial, 2018. $18.99. unp. ISBN 978-0-525-55272-7. Ages 8-11. P6Q7
Meltzer has taken his mediocre book about Gandhi, I Am Gandhi, and made it into a graphic narrative with the help of 25 different artists. The language expands the first book as Meltzer follows the life of the Indian man who developed a strategy of peaceful protesting during his 23 years in South Africa before he returned to India to lead a nonviolent revolution intended to free his country from British rule. The book covers key events in Gandhi’s life—his training as a lawyer, the Salt March to the ocean because the British forced Indians to buy the salt they produced, the British massacre of striking Indians, his fasts, and his years in prison. Proceeds to the book’s creators go to Seeds of Peace.
Verdict: Most of the artists’ illustrations work together well, but the narrative is disturbed by a young boy who frequently pops up and shouts, “Truth Force.” Because of the similarity of the books’ names, buyers should be sure to purchase the one with the subtitle, A Graphic Biography of a Hero.
April/May 2018 review by Nel Ward.
Jamieson, Victoria. All’s Faire in Middle School. Dial, 2017. $20.99. 248p. ISBN 978-0-525-42998-2. Ages 10-13. P8Q8
The first graphic novel following this author’s Newbery Honor-winning Roller Girl deals with Imogen “Impy” Vega’s struggles in middle school after being homeschooled by immersion in Renaissance fair culture. Her parents focus on their participation in that world although her father has a job outside the fairs. During the 11-year-old girl’s early days at school she tries to understand how to make friends, dress, behave, and deal with an arrogant science teacher while she makes poor choices in all of these. Impy is a good-hearted person who has all the problems of her peers, including embarrassment about her father’s position as actor and her mother’s retail hut. The artwork uses medieval themes with faux illuminated manuscript beginning each chapter and borders using heraldic crests as well as dragons and bunnies.
Verdict: Throughout the book, Impy faces lessons—both academic and personal—with one of the best being her bad treatment of her young brother that she overcomes. Jamieson also communicates lessons from racist characters without being didactic. The large number of characters keeps the interest in all of Impy’s worlds—school, home, and the Renaissance fair. An enjoyable read.
January/February 2018 review by Nel Ward.
Meltzer, Brad. Ordinary People Change the World series. Illus. by Christopher Eliopoulos. Dial, 2017. $14.99. 40p. Ages 4-7. I Am Gandhi. ISBN 978-0-7352-2870-2; I Am Sacagawea. ISBN 978-0-525-42853-4.
The series uses stereotyped illustrations and a sketchy narrative with comic book bubbles to depict the lives of famous people.
Verdict: A few photographs and a timeline are appended at the end of each book. The illustrations are culturally insensitive and the narration flip. The distortion of Gandhi’s quote “In a gentle way, you can shake the world” to “I will shake the world” belies the knowledge that Gandhi did not take credit for his work or claim that he could perform that action. In Sacagawea, a Native American holding a tomahawk is looking down on Sacagawea’s very short husband. Lewis and Clark are shown meeting Sacagawea in heavy snow at a fort, but she met them on November 11—before the snow and before the fort was built. Not recommended.
December 2017 review by Nel Ward.
Bradley, Kimberly Brubaker. The War I Finally Won. Dial, 2017. $16.99. 385p. ISBN 978-0-525-42920-3. Ages 10-14. P7Q9
In the sequel to Newbery Honor winner The War That Saved My Life, 11-year-old Ada has surgery to fix her clubfoot before she moves back to the English countryside, trying to avoid the bombing during World War II. Class issues arise as the recently orphaned girl who grew up in poverty lives with her younger brother, a young lesbian woman from the middle class and a privileged older woman from nobility. Bradley aptly depicts the struggles of Ada’s feelings about her mother, moving between gratitude that she is safe from the abuse and guilt at those feelings. Complicating the lives of the characters is a German Jewish refugee who is housed with them. Lady Thorton’s hatred for all Germans generates difficulty for everyone, but Ada’s patient guardian, Susan, gives Ada a sense of security. Sufficient information about the first book makes this book a read-alone, and the events surrounding Ada are tear-jerking.
Verdict: The development of all the major characters is realistic as is the depiction of deprivation and sacrifice during the war in England. Ada’s growth from a terrified girl to wisdom and understanding despite her physical and emotional pain makes the book a fascinating read.
November 2017 review by Nel Ward.
Luyken, Corinna. The Book of Mistakes. Dial, 2017. $18.99. unp. ISBN 978-0-7352-2792-7. Ages 4-7. P9Q9
“It started with one mistake,” begins the book begins, and the artist continues to repair those mistakes in illustrations, only to make more. With black ink, colored pencils, and watercolor on white pages, the illustrator starts with three marks inside a circle that becomes a face and moves to a highly complex illustration of a balloon-filled tree sheltering a group of frolicking children before returning to the circle. The debut picture book provides a valuable lesson for children who grow frustrated when they think they have ruined an art project. In lyrical text, Luyken admits her mistakes and notes changes that work for her.
Verdict: The author offers inspiration to young readers in the way, for example, the way that “the ink smudges scattered across the sky/look as if they could be leaves— / like they’d always wanted to be lifted up / and carried.” A bonus is the detail, often humorous, in the art.
Summer 2017 review by Nel Ward.
Bruchac, Joseph. Talking Leaves. Dial Books for Young Readers, 2016. $16.99. ISBN 9780803735088. 235 pgs. Ages 10+. P7Q8.
Uwahali, age 13, is excited when he learns that his father has returned to their hometown after being away for many years. When he begins hearing rumors that his father (the historical figure Sequoyah, developer of the Cherokee alphabet) is either crazy or a witch, he feels conflicted, but is determined to get to know his father and to try to understand his obsession with strange symbols. After learning that Sequoyah is trying to create a syllabary for the Cherokee language, and to help his people become literate in their own language, he realizes what a powerful and important idea this is. The novel works in Cherokee teaching stories, folklore, and information about the language in an accessible style. It delves into ideas about living without family, sacrificing for things you believe are important, and standing up to dangerous and ignorant people when necessary. At the end of the book, there is a list of the Cherokee alphabet with the corresponding sounds, a glossary, and a list of books for further reading. Verdict: This novel will provide good context for studies about Native American culture and the history of the Cherokee. It’s also an entertaining story and fast read about a young character that middle grade children will identify with.
November 2016 review by Carol Schramm.
McCormick, Scott. Camping CATastrophe! (Mr. Pants series, #4) Il. R.H. Lazzell. Dial, 2016. $12.99. 128p. ISBN 9780525428121. Ages 7-10. P8Q7
In the fourth of this graphic chapter book series, the three cats explore the great out of doors. Only the boys are allowed to join the Rugged Rangers, but Mr. Pants’ sister Foot Foot is the one who excels. Fortunately, Mr. Pants finds a club which appreciates his skill at selling cupcakes. Fun reading for lovers of Squish and Babymouse.
Fall 2016 review by Nel Ward.